So this costume turned out to be ADORABLE. We got so many comments at the fair, not to mention from our many Facebook friends after I plastered my page with photos. We definitely took lots of pics in costume, however, I was so pressed for time while making it that I didn't really take photos of the process. The good news is that I pretty much used the straight pattern pieces with little or no departure from the instructions.
Here is pretty much how it went down: I used the straight pattern of Simplicity 2788 for the baby costume, using white cotton muslin for the body suit and headpiece, black velveteen for the outside ears, cuffs, and booties, and a peach satin for the inside of the ears.
Simplicity 5582
I borrowed a child's hoopskirt, the shepherd's crook, and the lady's colonial straw hat from the world's greatest costume shop, Performing Arts Supply. I didn't use a petticoat, though I wish that I had. I like the rounder shape of the skirt in the illustration more than the conical shape of the hoop that I'm wearing. I believe the panniers would have looked better too.
Here's a photo of the three of us. Dad was dressed as The Big Bad Wolf (he's such a good sport)!
Oh, and PS, I believe I will be selling this costume (Bo Peep and sheep only, no wolf!) as the first item in my Etsy Shop.
Abby